I was kind of boring and went for the green and smoke as I felt it looked the most natural.
I like the idea of having a brown natural look pleo as well. And I especially like the yellow eyes. Actually brownish amber eye colour with dark olive green veins through the eyes would probe look more realistic and reptilian though that’s probe taking things too far.
This is really hard to decide the best way of going forward. It seems to me that there are two opposite camps. Those who want a more naturalistic looking pleo, and those who would like a more flamboyant brighter pleo. Rather than trying to meat the two half way but why not have a design for both?
Not being much help I know but what you’d need to do is a pole for the more natural colours IE base colour underside colour and eye colour. Then another pole doing the same for the brighter colours. That should give you two preferred designs at the end, one for each pole . Then you can see which of the two people prefer, the natural look one or the brighter one. Though I suspect that it will probably be half and half at that point.
I like the tiger striped pleo but would prefer something more along the colours and markings of say a leopard gecko for instance.
Louise